An apparatus for supporting tubing in casing includes a setting tool and a liner top packer, which can be used for tieback. A setting slip is disposed uphole of a packing assembly on the packer and is movable from a retracted to an extended state engaging the casing. The setting tool has a temporary connection to the packer and has a pack-off that seals the tool in the packer but allows for movement. After running downhole, the temporary connection of the setting tool to the packer is disconnected, and the setting slip is set in the casing by moving the setting tool in an uphole direction. To set the packing assembly, the packer is moved in the uphole direction by engaging the setting tool with the pack-off and compressing the packing element (e.g., packing element and opposing cones and slips) against the set setting slip. Eventually, the setting tool is disconnected from the packer by disengaging the pack-off.