A tick removal ointment which is a topical composition having 25% benzocaine incorporated in white petroleum jelly. The amount of benzocaine in the tick removal ointment is efficacious for numbing the tick and hence causes the tick to release or self-extricate from the host mammal, optimally prior to the transmission of disease organisms from the tick to the host mammal. Upon the self-extrication of the tick from the host mammal, the white petroleum jelly is efficacious for killing the tick. Application of the present tick removal ointment eliminates the need to make direct contact with the tick to remove the tick and further eliminates the task of observing the mammal for a ii period of time because the composition is devised to first release the tick from the host mammal and then to kill the tick once the tick is released from the host mammal.