One embodiment provides a method, including: receiving, at an electronic device, a request to play media content; accessing, using a processor of the electronic device, a list of user devices; identifying, using the processor, user specific contextual data associated with the list of user devices; selecting, using the processor, a user device from the list of user devices based on the user specific contextual data; and playing, with the user device selected, the media content. Other aspects are described and claimed.