Generally described, aspects of the disclosed subject matter are directed to dampers having shimmed pistons. In accordance with aspects of the present disclosure, the dampers generally include a shaft having a piston with compression and rebound valves extending therethrough. The piston interfaces a shim assembly at the valve outlets such that damping fluid flow is controlled through a set of valves in one direction, and the damping fluid flow is limited through the same set of valves in the opposite direction. In this regard, the shim assembly is configured to deflect away from the piston as a result of damping fluid flow through the first valve. The shim assembly generally includes a ring shim that interfaces a shim stack to provide a configurable preload for the deflectable shims.