An auto indexing method includes identifying a vault of a dispersed storage network for an auto indexing function. The method continues by obtaining search criteria for the auto indexing function. The method further includes scanning the plurality of metadata files to identify metadata files of the plurality of metadata files having at least one of the objective metadata and the subjective metadata corresponding to the search criterion. The method further includes updating an index file that includes the identity of the one or more metadata files of the plurality of metadata files having the at least one of the objective metadata and the subjective metadata corresponding to the search criterion and updating an index structure based on the index file. The method further includes utilizing the index structure to search for one or more data objects having one or more of the search criterion of the search criteria.