In one embodiment, a method includes determining that a notification is to be displayed on a first portion of a touchscreen of a first computing device. The method also includes determining a point on a surface of the touchscreen in which a user of the first computing device intends to imminently touch the touchscreen. Also, the method includes determining whether a second portion of the touchscreen includes a currently-displayed interactive touch component, the second portion of the touchscreen being defined by the point and predetermined areas of the touchscreen adjacent to and surrounding the point. Moreover, the method includes modifying at least one aspect of the notification in response to a determination that the second portion of the touchscreen includes and/or overlaps with the first portion of the touchscreen. Additional embodiments for adaptively modifying notification settings for implementation on a touchscreen display are also described.