A method begins with a processing module querying distributed storage network (DSN) storage units regarding storage errors associated with a data segment. The method continues with the processing module receiving query responses and depending on the responses, assigning a first threshold priority or a second threshold priority to encoded data slices (EDSs) associated with the data segment. The method proceeds with the processing module, depending on the assigned threshold priority, issuing read slice requests and rebuilding EDS associated with the data segment.