A method for consumer verification of a payment transaction that exceeds previously established account limitations includes: storing account profiles, each including data related to a transaction account including a primary account number and transaction controls; receiving a transaction message related to a payment transaction including a specific primary account number, a point of sale identifier, and one or more additional data elements configured to store transaction details; identifying a specific account profile that includes the specific primary account number; determining that the payment transaction exceeds the account controls in the specific account profile based on the transaction details; transmitting question data for a plurality of questions to a point of sale associated with the point of sale identifier; receiving answer data from the point of sale; and transmitting the transaction message to a financial institution based on the answer data.