An automated presentation review system includes a controller in communication with a user device, the user device comprising an input mechanism and a display mechanism, a memory coupled to the controller. The controller displays a graphical user interface through which a presentation review window is displayed. The presentation review window simultaneously provides a presentation display frame displaying a presentation comprising plurality of presentation slides, a review criteria tool displaying a plurality of review criteria options, and a results display frame. The controller then receives a selection one or more review criteria options from the plurality of review criteria options, and, in response to the receipt of the selected review criteria options, display results of an analysis of the presentation based on the selected review criteria options, wherein the display of the analysis includes one or more icons signifying an inconsistency identified in the presentation across the plurality of presentation slides.