One general aspect of device reservation state preservation in accordance with the present description, provides for an intermediate reservation state, referred to herein as a “peer” reservation state, which may be maintained by a storage controller in the event of a total loss of communication connectivity to the reserving host so long as a peer or partner storage controller of a mirror relationship still has communication connectivity to the host. The peer reservation state as used herein, is a reservation state intermediate between a full reservation state for a device, and a fully released state in which a reservation of the device has been completely released. Other features and aspects may be realized, depending upon the particular application.