Systems and methods are provided for use in provisioning digital identities for users. One exemplary method includes receiving, at a card device, an authentication request and a captured first biometric of a user, from a communication device associated with the user, and comparing the first biometric and a first biometric reference at the card device, in response to the first biometric reference being stored at the card device. The method also includes capturing, at the card device, a second biometric of the user and comparing the second biometric to a second biometric reference stored at the card device. The method further includes compiling a response to the authentication request including a first indicator of the comparison of the first biometric to the first biometric reference and a second indicator of the comparison of the second biometric to the second biometric reference, and transmitting the response to the communication device.