Systems, devices, media, and methods are presented for identifying unread elements and presentation context to generate real-time indicators for the unread elements. The systems and methods receive an indication identifying a member and identify content for presentation to the member. The systems and methods determine one or more presentation parameters for the content and one or more content parameters for the content. The systems and methods generate a content representation of the content for presentation within a user interface based on the presentation parameters and the content parameters, and cause presentation of the content representation at the client device associated with the member.