A system receives a first alert pertaining to a main part from a managed information handling system, determines whether an alternative part is available at the managed information handling system as a substitute for the main part, and determines a life expectancy of the alternative part. The system may also determine whether an expected level of service can be expected to be provided by the alternative part based on the life expectancy of the alternative part, select between a plurality of levels of criticality to apply to the first alert, and dispatch the first alert for resolution at a selected level of criticality.