The disclosed fraud risk scoring tool provides data-driven identification of potential fraud cases. A fraud risk score is determined based at least on a weighted sum of multiple metrics, where weights are determined based on precision or inverse variance and suspension propensity importance, which is indicative of variable importance. An exemplary method includes: receiving and aggregating transaction metrics across customer IDs to produce an aggregated transaction metric data set; determining, for each aggregated transaction metric in the aggregated transaction metric data set, a precision value, a suspension propensity importance, and a scoring weight based at least on one of the precision value and the suspension propensity importance; determining, for each customer ID within the plurality of customer IDs, a risk score based at least on the scoring weights applied to corresponding transaction metrics and a risk priority; and reporting at least one customer ID associated with a selected risk priority.