Methods, apparatus, systems and articles of manufacture are disclosed to verify encrypted handshakes. An example apparatus includes a message copier to clone a client introductory message, the client introductory message is included in a first handshake for network communication between a client and a server, a connection establisher to initiate a second handshake between the apparatus and the server based on the cloned client introductory message, and a decrypter to, in response to the second handshake, decrypt a certificate sent by the server.