Disclosed herein are systems and method for multiplexing data of an underlying index. In an exemplary aspect, an index handler may generate a plurality of slots and a plurality of data buckets for a traditional index. The index handler may receive, from a software application, a request to access a data file. The index handler may determine whether any slot of the plurality of slots is attached to a respective data bucket of the plurality of data buckets comprising the data file. In response to determining that a first slot of the plurality of slots is attached to a first data bucket comprising the data file, the index handler may enable, via the first data bucket attached to the first slot, access to the data file to the software application.