Protocol-agnostic configuration of an identity claim policy that is to be implemented in one or more applications according to one of multiple identity authentication protocols and verification of the protocol-agnostic claims configuration. First, one or more protocol-agnostic identity claim policies are generated and applied to one or more applications. Each of the one or more applications implement one of the multiple identity authentication protocols. For each of the one or more applications, the implemented identity authentication policy is determined. Based on the determined identity authentication protocol, one or more identity claims of the corresponding application that corresponds to the at least one identity claim policy is then construed.