Methods, systems, and apparatus, including computer programs encoded on a computer storage medium, to generate a custom seismic surface and volume attribute. In one aspect, a method includes receiving a seismic cube and a seismic surface, and the seismic cube includes traces recorded at receivers deployed to collect seismic data. The seismic surface is picked on the seismic cube. Seismic wavelets are extracted with a selected length from the seismic cube along an intersection with the seismic surface for each spatial coordinate associated with the seismic surface. A reference wavelet is determined. A surface attribute map is generated based on comparing each of the seismic wavelets to the reference wavelet. A productivity of the seismic surface is evaluated using the surface attribute map.