Fast verification of data integrity of non-volatile memory cells is disclosed. In one aspect, an estimate is made of a bit error rate (BER) associated with the data to be verified without fully decoding the data. If the estimated BER is below a threshold, then the storage system reports that the data meets a data integrity criterion. If the estimated BER is above the threshold, the storage system may decode the data to determine a BER and report whether the data meets the data integrity criterion based on the determined BER. The estimate of the BER may be based on a syndrome weight of the data, a BER of an XOR codeword formed from multiple codewords of the data, or a BER of a sample of the data. Hence, considerable time and power are saved verifying data integrity, at least when the data is not fully decoded.