Embodiments are directed to interaction with an open-domain question and answer system by recognizing questions that are highly broad or abstract, and generating and processing a batch of questions expressing alternate, concrete instances of the more general, abstract question. Responses to all of the questions in the batch are considered as candidates, and the strongest general answers are returned. A weighted, ranked answer set, based on weighting individual concrete questions and scaling the answers proportional to the weight of the questions, is provided to the user. The approach, according to embodiments herein, addresses the need for responses to broad questions in which a response to any of a set of more concrete question instances may serve to answer the question.