A washing machine appliance and a fluid additive dispenser therefor are provided. The washing machine appliance includes a wash tub and a wash basket rotatably mounted within the wash tub. The fluid additive dispenser includes a reservoir defining a first cup for a first additive and an outlet in fluid communication with the wash basket. The fluid additive dispenser also includes a second cup for a second additive. The second cup is disposed within the first cup and separated from the first cup. The second cup is also in fluid communication with the wash basket via the outlet of the first cup.