A video content item may be provided to a user in a first area of a graphical user interface (GUI). Related video content items may be provided in a second area of the GUI. A selection of a control element provided in the GUI may be received where the selection of the control element indicates that the user is interested in a first audio component that is included in the first audio content item. In response to receiving the selection of the control element, a plurality of second audio components that are included in different video content items and are similar to the first audio component may be identified and the second area of the GUI may be modified to prioritize a presentation of at least one of the different video content items that includes at least one of the second audio components over a presentation of the related video content items in the second area of the GUI.