A method and system are described for controlling access to online applications using memetic authenticators that are de-identified and passwordless. The method includes curating, issuing ownership, and registering memetic authenticators. The method involves assembling an authenticator package including a fingerprint hash value, matched pairs of user-selected memetic authenticator records, a timer, and encrypting the package using a cipher issued and uniquely-assigned by a service provider. Ciphers may be regenerated on each authentication event providing for episodic re-verification. Fingerprints assign ownership for memetic authenticators, with such associations stored on networked nodes of a distributed database. On authenticating, the client-supplied authenticator package is decrypted and compared to ownership records on an identity network for verification and granting or denying access. The method provides for multilateral verification by retrieving ownership claims from multiple nodes during authentication events. At no time does any party to the system possess everything required to authenticate.