Methods, systems, and non-transitory computer readable media are disclosed for determining a sub-set of user-submitted images that are similar to a curated image and presenting the sub-set of user-submitted images in connection with the curated image. The disclosed system presents a curated image depicting a product via a graphical user interface (e.g., on an e-commerce platform). In one or more embodiments, the disclosed system extracts feature vectors from the curated image and a plurality of user-submitted images. The disclosed system compares the feature vectors from the curated image and the plurality of user-submitted images to determine a sub-set of user-submitted images that are similar to the curated image. The disclosed system presents the sub-set of user-submitted images based on a user selection of the curated image.