Methods, systems, and non-transitory computer readable media are disclosed for generating a composite image comprising objects in positions from two or more different digital images. In one or more embodiments, the disclosed system receives a sequence of images and identifies objects within the sequence of images. In one example, the disclosed system determines a target position for a first object based on detecting user selection of the first object in the target position from a first image. The disclosed system can generate a fixed object image comprising the first object in the target position. The disclosed system can generate preview images comprising the fixed object image with the second object sequencing through a plurality of positions as seen in the sequence of images. Based on a second user selection of a desired preview image, the disclosed system can generate the composite image.