Disclosed are systems, methods, and non-transitory computer-readable media for routing provider queues. A message routing system receives a request to transmit a message to a destination device and selects a first routing provider from a plurality of routing providers that each have a separate message queue of a plurality of message queues, wherein the first routing provider is selected based on one or more characteristics of each of the plurality of routing providers. The message routing system adds the message into a first message queue designated to the first routing provider, and causes the message to be dequeued from the first message queue to the first routing provider for delivery to the destination device.