A threaded insert with a replaceable nut element allows a user to replace only the nut element of the threaded insert rather than the entire threaded insert. The threaded insert includes an insertable housing, a replaceable nut, a retaining mechanism, and an attachment mechanism. The insertable housing allows the threaded insert to be engaged within a wall structure and is used to contain the replaceable nut. The replaceable nut allows the threaded insert to be engaged by a fastener such as a screw or bolt. The attachment mechanism allows the replaceable nut to be attached within and detached from the insertable housing. The retaining mechanism further secures the replaceable nut within the insertable housing and also prevents the replaceable nut from rotating within the insertable housing.