Systems and methods are provided for enabling an enhanced group watch session. A group session for consuming a first media content item is initiated between first and second computing devices, and a first portion of the first media content item is received at the computing devices. It is identified, based on a first user profile, that the first computing device is configured to receive a second media content item at a first time, and it is identified, based on a second user profile, that the second computing device is configured to not receive a second media content item at the first time. A first user interface element associated with performing an action is generated for output, and a first input associated with the user interface element is received. The action is performed at the second computing device.