A cache system that includes a reverse cache and a main cache is disclosed. The reverse cache is configured to identify candidates for insertion into a main cache. The reverse cache stores entries such as fingerprints and index values, which are representations of or that identify data. When the entry has been accessed multiple times or is a candidate for promotion based on operation of the reverse cache, data corresponding to the entry is promoted to the main cache. The main cache is configured to evict entries using recency, frequency, and time-adjustments. The main cache and the reverse cache may be similarly configured with a recent list, a frequent list, and/or ghost lists, but operate differently.