Systems and methods for extracting data from electronic documents using optical character recognition (OCR) and non-OCR based text extraction. A server computing device initiates non-OCR based text extraction for each page of an electronic document. The server calculates a document text coverage percentage corresponding to the non-OCR based text extraction for the whole document and, in response to determining that the document text coverage percentage is below a first threshold, initiates OCR for the document. The server calculates a page text coverage percentage corresponding to the non-OCR based text extraction for one or more pages of the electronic document and, in response to determining that the page text coverage percentage is below a second threshold, initiates OCR for the pages. The server combines first text extracted from the electronic document using non-OCR based text extraction and second text extracted from the electronic document using OCR.