Determining and applying a cache replacement policy for a computer application running in a computer processing system is accomplished by receiving a processor core data request, adding bits on each cache line of a plurality of cache lines to identify a core ID of an at least one processor core that provides each cache line in a shared cache, allocating a tag table for each processor core, where the tag table keeps track of an index of processor core miss rates, and setting a threshold to define a level of cache usefulness, depending on whether or not the index of processor core miss rates exceeds the threshold. Checking the threshold and when the threshold is not exceeded, then a shared cache standard policy for cache replacement is applied. When the threshold is exceeded, then the cache line from the processor core running the application is evicted from the shared cache.