A system and method for determining the criticality of each timing pin in a circuit design are disclosed. The criticality of a timing pin is the probability that the timing pin is on the path with the worst slack in the circuit design. According to the methodology, the slack for each timing pin is calculated, wherein each slack is a function of a process random variable. Then, the criticality of each timing pin is determined as the probability of the timing pin having the minimum slack among the slacks in an independent critical set of timing pins. The criticality of each timing pin may then be normalized. By determining the criticalities of the timing pins in a circuit design, a circuit design system may be able to more easily identify portions of the circuit design that need modification for timing and other purposes.