Personal care compositions suitable for use in skin care applications, which effectively deliver and/or deposit anti-inflammatory and anti-microbial agents, which are relatively non-irritating, and thus suitable for use by people having irritated or sensitive skin, particularly the skin around the eyes of a user. The personal care composition comprises a first formulation that provides anti-irritant and anti-inflammatory properties that can be easily reformulated to a second formulation that includes an anti-microbial agent by simply adding an anti-microbial agent without having to completely begin with a new formula and without compromising the properties found in the first formulation.