A storage system, according to one embodiment, includes a processor and logic integrated with and/or executable by the processor. The logic is configured to: search for an instance of a file or portion thereof on a second storage tier; at least one of: associate the instance of the file or portion thereof on the second storage tier with a first user when the instance of the file or portion thereof is not associated with any user, and replicate the instance of the file or portion thereof on the second storage tier and associate the replicated instance of the file or portion thereof on the second storage tier with the first user; and disassociate an instance of the file on a first storage tier from the first user.