The present invention is directed to a composition containing: (a) at least one tackifier component having a glass transition temperature (Tg) of greater than about 20° C.; (b) at least one film former chosen from a propylphenylsilsesquioxane resin having a molecular weight of from about 2,000 to about 30,000 and comprising at least about 70 mole % propyl siloxy units and at most about 30 mole % phenyl siloxy units, and a propylsilsesquioxane wax substituted with alkyl units having at least 30 carbons; (c) a liquid fatty phase comprising at least one volatile hydrocarbon compound; (d) at least one colorant; (e) optionally, water; and (f) optionally, at least one emulsifier. Also disclosed is a method of making up keratinous substrates involving applying the above composition onto the keratinous substrates.