Disclosed are non-aqueous compositions capable of forming a gel structure, containing: (a) a low molecular mass N-acyl glutamic acid diamide having a straight-chain alkyl group; (b) a low molecular mass N-acyl glutamic acid diamide having a branched-chain alkyl group; (c) at least one gel-promoting solvent; (d) at least one film former; (e) at least one volatile solvent capable of solubilizing the film former; and (f) at least one colorant; and (g) a polyorganosiloxane-containing polymer, wherein the composition has a hardness value ranging from about 30 to about 300 gf, a melting point of about 500 C or higher, does not require use of wax as a structuring agent. Methods of making and using the compositions are also disclosed.