Placement of object replicas in a distributed storage system includes, at a first instance, opening a journal for storage of object chunks. An object is received, which comprises one or more chunks. Each chunk comprises one or more storage blocks. The blocks for a single chunk are stored in a single journal. Global metadata for the object is stored, which includes a list of chunks for the object. Local metadata for the chunk is stored, which includes a block list identifying each block of the plurality of blocks. The local metadata is associated with the journal. The journal is later closed. The journal is subsequently replicated to a second instance. The global metadata is updated to reflect the replication, whereas the local metadata is unchanged by the replication.