A guitar pick dispenser may include a dispenser body. The dispenser body may include a bottom and a side wall attached to the bottom. The sidewall may define an opening opposite the bottom. A false bottom may be connected to the bottom by a resilient member. The resilient member may be configured to bias the false bottom toward the opening. A guitar pick retainer may be slidably disposed on the dispenser body. The guitar pick retainer may be further configured to partially cover the opening.