Methods, apparatus and computer program products implement embodiments of the present invention that include defining, in a storage system including receiving, by a processor, metadata describing a first cache configured as a master cache having non-destaged data, and defining, using the received metadata, a second cache configured as a backup cache for the master cache. Subsequent to defining the second cache, the non-destaged data is retrieved from the first cache, and the non-destaged data is stored to the second cache.