Systems and methods for detecting and scoring anomalies. In some embodiments, a method is provided, comprising acts of: identifying a plurality of attributes from a profile; for each attribute of the plurality of attributes, determining whether the digital interaction matches the profile with respect to the attribute, comprising: identifying, from the profile, at least one bucket of possible values of the attribute, the at least one bucket being indicative of anomalous behavior; identifying, from the digital interaction, a value of the attribute; and determining whether the value identified from the digital interaction falls into the at least one bucket, wherein the digital interaction is determined to match the profile with respect to the attribute if it is determined that the value identified from the digital interaction falls into the at least one bucket; and determining a penalty score.