Methods and structure for managing cache memory for a storage controller. One exemplary embodiment a Redundant Array of Independent Disks (RAID) storage controller. The storage controller includes an interface operable to receive Input/Output (I/O) requests from a host, a Direct Memory Access (DMA) module, a memory comprising cache data for a logical volume, and a control unit. The control unit is able to generate Scatter Gather Lists (SGLs) that indicate the location of cache data for incoming read requests. Each SGL is stored in the memory, and at least one SGL points to cache data that is no longer indexed by the cache. The control unit is also able to service an incoming read request based on the SGL, by directing the DMA module to transfer the cache data that is no longer indexed to the host.