An operating system (OS) of a processing system having a plurality of processor cores determines a cost associated with different mechanisms for performing a translation lookaside buffer (TLB) shootdown in response to, for example, a virtual address being remapped to a new physical address, and selects a TLB shootdown mechanism to purge outdated or invalid address translations from the TLB based on the determined cost. In some embodiments, the OS selects an inter-processor interrupt (IPI) as the TLB shootdown mechanism if the cost associated with sending an IPI is less than a threshold cost. In some embodiments, the OS compares the cost of using an IPI as the TLB shootdown mechanism versus the cost of sending a hardware broadcast to all processor cores of the processing system as the shootdown mechanism and selects the shootdown mechanism having the lower cost.